Toasty Oven Bake Shoppe

Indulge in the heartwarming flavors of traditional Amish baked goods, handcrafted with love by Alvin and Sarah Mast in New Holstein, WI. Their passion for quality shines through in every delicious creation, bringing you closer to the simple pleasures of home-cooked delights.

Explore a delightful selection of homemade jams bursting with fresh fruit flavors, rich and decadent chocolates to satisfy your sweet tooth, and scrumptious cookies perfect for any occasion. 

But the love doesn’t stop there—don’t forget your furry friends! Treat them to their specially made dog treats, crafted to ensure they enjoy the same wholesome goodness. 

Bring the taste of tradition to your table with Alvin and Sarah's homemade treasures. Perfect for gifting or savoring yourself, these authentic delights are sure to enchant everyone in the family!